While most pocket change is worth face value, these four extraordinary coins have sold for tens of thousands — and even millions — at auction.
Here’s why they’re so valuable and whether you should hold or sell if you ever find one in your collection.
🪙 1. 1943 Bronze Lincoln Cent — The Accidental $1.7 Million Penny 💰
💰 Record Sale: $1.7 Million (2010)
Why It’s Valuable:
➡️ Struck in 95% copper when only steel cents were authorized during WWII
➡️ Only 10–15 genuine specimens known to exist
➡️ One of the most famous minting mistakes in U.S. history
Hold or Sell?
✅ Hold: Prices rising 8–10% annually — great long-term investment
⚠️ Sell only if you need liquidity; population remains under 20 known coins
🦅 2. 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar — America’s First Silver Dollar 🇺🇸
💰 Record Sale: $12 Million (finest known)
Why It’s Valuable:
➡️ First official U.S. silver dollar ever struck
➡️ Only 140–150 coins survive today
➡️ Historically significant — cornerstone of American coinage
Hold or Sell?
✅ Hold long-term: Its historical importance makes it nearly priceless
⚠️ Sell only if offered over $500,000
🪙 3. 1913 Liberty Nickel — The Legendary 5-Coin Mystery 🔥
💰 Record Sale: $4.5 Million (2018)
Why It’s Valuable:
➡️ Only 5 known specimens in existence
➡️ Struck illegally after the design was discontinued
➡️ One of the most famous and mysterious coins in U.S. history
Hold or Sell?
✅ Hold indefinitely: Museum-grade rarity
⚠️ Never sell raw — must be PCGS or NGC certified for authentication
💫 4. 2000-P Sacagawea Dollar Mule — The $192,000 Error Coin 🦅
💰 Record Sale: $192,000 (finest known)
Why It’s Valuable:
➡️ Mint error: Washington quarter obverse paired with Sacagawea dollar reverse
➡️ Only 3 confirmed examples exist
➡️ The rarest modern U.S. Mint error coin
Hold or Sell?
⚠️ Sell now: Modern error coin prices may be peaking
✅ Keep only if graded MS67+ — top grades may continue to appreciate
📈 Coin Market Trends — 2025 Insights
Best to Hold Long-Term:
✔️ Pre-1900 coins (historical and museum value)
✔️ Ultra-rarities with fewer than 25 known pieces
✔️ Top-graded registry coins (MS/PR70)
Best to Sell Now:
⚠️ Raw or uncertified coins — market correction likely
⚠️ Modern error coins — short-term bubble possible
⚠️ Duplicates — free up capital for key-date investments
🧠 Expert Appraisal Advice
Need help deciding whether to hold or sell your coin?
Get a professional evaluation from our numismatic team!
📧 Email: consult@pennyverse.info
Subject: “HOLD OR SELL”
Include:
📸 High-quality front and back photos
📜 Certification info (PCGS, NGC, ANACS if available)
🎯 Your investment or collecting goals
