While billions were made, a major error at the U.S. Mint created a tiny number of these quarters that were accidentally struck on pure silver planchets. Finding one of these is a major discovery, with top-grade examples valued at over $15,000!
The Common Quarter vs. The Silver Treasure
To understand the treasure, you need to know what went wrong at the U.S. Mint.
- The Standard Quarter: Normal 2020 quarters are made of a “clad” composition of copper and nickel. They have a standard nickel-gray appearance and are not particularly valuable.
- The “Wrong Planchet” Error: The valuable error occurred when a blank planchet (a “coin blank”) made of 99.9% silver, intended for special collector “Silver Proof Sets” at the San Francisco Mint, was accidentally shipped to the Denver Mint. This silver blank was then fed into a regular press and struck with the 2020-D Weir Farm quarter dies. This created a major “off-metal” error.
The $15,000 Silver Error: A Genuine Modern Rarity
The high valuation for this coin is very real and is driven by its rarity and dramatic appearance.
- Why It’s So Valuable: It’s a spectacular, visually obvious mistake. A brilliant, silver-white quarter from the Denver mint immediately stands out. These “wrong planchet” errors are highly sought after by error specialists, and very few are known to exist for any given modern date.
- The Path to $15,000: The value is heavily dependent on the coin’s condition. While even a circulated example would be worth thousands, the $15,000 price tag is for a pristine, uncirculated specimen that has been professionally certified with a very high grade (such as MS67 or MS68). A bidding war at a major auction for a top-tier example could easily push the price to this level. The strike on a softer silver planchet might even bring out extra details in the portrait, as hinted at by the arrows in your photo.
How to Spot This Modern Silver Rarity: A 3-Step Guide
You don’t need to be an expert to spot this error, but you do need to be observant and have one crucial tool: a digital scale.
- Step 1: The Edge Test This is your first and easiest visual clue. Look at the side of your 2020 quarters.
- A normal clad quarter will have a distinct copper stripe in the middle.
- The rare silver error will have a SOLID, brilliant silver edge, with no copper core visible.
- Step 2: The Weight Test (The Definitive Proof) A digital gram scale is a must-have for any serious coin hunter. The weight difference is significant and undeniable.
- A normal clad 2020 quarter weighs 5.67 grams.
- A 99.9% SILVER quarter weighs noticeably more: 6.34 grams. If your silver-edged 2020-D quarter weighs around 6.34 grams, you have almost certainly found this incredible error!
- Step 3: The “Look and Feel” A coin struck on a silver planchet will have a brighter, “whiter” luster than a standard nickel-clad coin. It may also have a slightly different sound when dropped on a hard surface (though we don’t recommend this test as it can cause damage!).
You Found It! Where and How to Sell Your $15,000 Coin
If you find a 2020-D quarter that is silver and weighs over 6 grams, you are holding a major numismatic discovery. Follow these steps precisely.
- Protect It Immediately:
- Handle the coin only by its edges. Place it in a protective, inert holder (like a 2×2 flip). DO NOT CLEAN IT.
- Get It Authenticated (The “Where”):
- To get real value, the coin must be certified by one of the top-tier grading services in the United States: PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) in California or NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company) in Florida. They will verify it as a genuine “Struck on Silver Planchet” error.
- Sell Through a Major Auction House (The “How” and “Where”):
- Once certified, a coin of this value is best sold through a world-renowned auction house to reach top collectors.
- The Best Places to Sell: Major U.S.-based firms like Heritage Auctions (Dallas, New York), Stack’s Bowers Galleries (California, New York), or the online powerhouse GreatCollections Coin Auctions (California).
- How to Sell: You “consign” the coin to them. They will handle the photography, marketing, and auctioning of the coin to their global network of wealthy buyers, ensuring you receive the highest possible price.
For more coin hunting tips and stories on amazing discoveries, be sure to visit us at pennyverse.info!
Think you have a 2020 quarter that looks silver? Share clear photos of the front, back, AND EDGE with our community! 
