Most Sacagawea dollars are only worth face value ($1)… but a few rare error varieties can transform an ordinary coin into life-changing money.
Here’s how to spot the 3 most valuable Sacagawea dollar errors — including the legendary $80,000 mule coin — and where to sell them for top dollar.
The $80,000 “Mule Error” (Quarter + Sacagawea Hybrid)
Why It’s Rare
- Wrong obverse: Washington quarter front + Sacagawea dollar reverse
- Only 13 known examples (struck in 2000 at Philadelphia Mint)
How to Identify
Front: Should show George Washington instead of Sacagawea
Edge: Smooth edge (quarters normally have reeded edges)
Record Sale: $84,000 (PCGS MS65, 2022)
The “Wounded Eagle” Error ($150 – $500)
The Scratch That Pays
- Caused by a die gouge, leaving a raised line across the eagle’s chest
- Not post-mint damage — it must be part of the original strike
Value by Grade
- AU-50: Around $150
- MS-65: Up to $500
The “Cheerios Dollar” ($3,000 – $12,000)
Breakfast Box Rarity
- 2000-P only: 5,500 special coins placed in Cheerios boxes as a promo
- Key Feature: Sharply detailed tail feathers (normal coins look flat)
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Normal 2000-P | Cheerios Dollar |
|---|---|
| Flat feathers | Detailed, crisp tail feathers |
| Worth $1 | Worth $3,000+ |
Record Sale: $12,000 (PCGS MS69, 2018)
Where to Sell Rare Sacagawea Dollars
- Auction Houses: Heritage Auctions (best for $5,000+)
- GreatCollections: For mid-range coins ($500 – $5,000)
- Private Collectors: CoinTalk forums (no fees, but trust required)
- eBay: Best for lower-value Wounded Eagles ($150 – $500)
3 Deadly Mistakes to Avoid
Cleaning/polishing coins (destroys value)
Selling uncertified (PCGS/NGC slabs boost value by 50–300%)
Ignoring coin rolls (banks still distribute Sacagawea dollars!)
