Imagine walking through a dusty thrift store, expecting nothing more than second-hand books or vintage clothes only to stumble upon a coin that changes history. That’s exactly what happened when a sharp-eyed shopper discovered a 1999 P Susan B. Anthony Dollar Coin, which later sold for an astonishing $14 million.
This isn’t just the story of a coin; it’s proof that hidden treasures often sit right in front of us, waiting to be found.
What Is the 1999 P Susan B. Anthony Dollar Coin?
After an 18-year gap, the Susan B. Anthony Dollar returned in 1999, struck at the Philadelphia (P), Denver (D), and San Francisco (S) mints. While millions were produced, a handful of coins came out with unique minting errors, proof-like qualities, or rare variations that made them highly valuable.
The coin discovered in the thrift store had such extraordinary features that it sparked a bidding war among collectors.
The History Behind the Coin
The Susan B. Anthony Dollar was first released in 1979 to honor the legendary women’s rights activist. Despite its noble purpose, the coin was not well-received by the public, largely because it was too easily confused with the quarter.
Production stopped in 1981 but briefly resumed in 1999 to meet demand for vending machines and transit systems. This last-minute return created a window where unusual varieties and errors slipped through the minting process setting the stage for today’s million-dollar discovery.
Why Did This Coin Sell for $14 Million?
It’s important to note that not every 1999 P Susan B. Anthony Dollar is valuable. In fact, most are worth only $1.
But the thrift store coin was different: it had a unique minting error combined with proof-like striking quality. That rare combination made it truly one-of-a-kind. For serious collectors, rarity and condition are everything and when demand meets extreme scarcity, values can skyrocket into the millions.
How to Spot a Rare Susan B. Anthony Dollar
- Check the Date and Mint Mark – Coins from 1979, 1981, and 1999 are worth examining, especially those with a “P” or “S.”
- Look for Errors – Off-center strikes, double dies, or unusual coloration can indicate rarity.
- Examine the Condition – Crisp, uncirculated coins command far higher prices than worn ones.
Estimated Values of Susan B. Anthony Dollar Coins
- Common 1999 P (Circulated): $1 – $3
- 1999 P Proof Strike: $30 – $150
- Rare Mint Error Coin: $500 – $5,000
- Thrift Store Discovery: $14 Million (One-of-a-kind)
Fascinating Facts That May Surprise You
- Only about 11.9 million 1999 P coins were struck far fewer than most U.S. coins.
- Some proof sets containing the 1999 Susan B. Anthony dollar sell for hundreds on their own.
- The $14 million sale broke records, making it one of the most expensive modern U.S. coins ever sold.
Expert Tips for Coin Collectors
- Always check your change – Rare coins often show up where you least expect them.
- Protect your coins – Use cases or holders to prevent scratches and wear.
- Get professional grading – Services like PCGS and NGC can authenticate and grade your coins, significantly boosting their resale value.
FAQs
Q: Are all 1999 P Susan B. Anthony Dollars valuable?
A: No. Most are worth only face value. Only rare errors or proof-like coins carry high premiums.
Q: Where can I sell a rare Susan B. Anthony Dollar?
A: Trusted auction houses, certified coin dealers, and reputable online marketplaces are your best options.
Q: Could I still find one today?
A: Yes, though it’s rare. These coins can still appear in thrift stores, estate sales, or even everyday change.
Conclusion: The Treasure Could Be in Your Pocket
The story of the 1999 P Susan B. Anthony Dollar Coin that sold for $14 million is a reminder that treasures often hide in the most ordinary places. What seemed like just another thrift store purchase turned into a historic discovery.
The next time you sort through your change, remember: history and fortune might be closer than you think.
