The Next Tier of Million-Dollar U.S. Coins: Gold Rarities Worth $8.9M+

These Historic Gold Coins Represent Numismatic Royalty

While not quite reaching the stratospheric prices of the 20M+coins,thesethreegoldpieceshaveeachcommanded∗∗20M+coins,thesethreegoldpieceshaveeachcommanded∗∗8.9 to $10 million** at auction, making them some of the most valuable collectibles in American history. Here’s why they’re worth fortunes.


1. 1822 Capped Bust Gold $5 Half Eagle

💰 Record Sale: $10,012,723

The Rarest Early U.S. Gold Coin

1822 Half Eagle

Why It Commands Eight Figures:

  • Only 3 Known Specimens: All traced to the famous Bass Collection
  • Early Federal Mint Rarity: Struck during America’s monetary infancy
  • Historic Design: Features John Reich’s iconic capped bust design

Key Identifiers:

  • Weight: 8.36g (0.2419 oz of 91.67% gold)
  • Diameter: 25mm
  • Edge: Reeded
  • Mintmark: None (Philadelphia issue)

Last Auction: Heritage 2021 – $10,012,723


2. 1870-S Indian Princess Head Gold $3

💰 Record Sale: $8,969,300

The San Francisco Mint Mystery

1870-S $3 Gold

What Makes It Special:

  • Single Known Example: Resides in the Smithsonian
  • Mint Record Anomaly: No official records of its production exist
  • Transitional Design: Last year of the Indian Princess motif

Authentication Points:

  • Weight: 5.01g (0.1607 oz of 90% gold)
  • Diameter: 20.5mm
  • Edge: Reeded
  • Mintmark: “S” below wreath

Note: Never publicly sold – valuation based on insurance appraisal


3. 1861 Paquet Reverse $20 Double Eagle

💰 Record Sale: $8,968,870

The Civil War Gold Treasure

1861 Paquet Reverse

Why Collectors Prize It:

  • Ultra-Rare Variety: Only 2-3 confirmed specimens
  • Historic Timing: Struck as the Civil War began
  • Design Flaw: High relief caused stacking issues, leading to quick redesign

Distinctive Features:

  • Weight: 33.44g (1.075 oz of 90% gold)
  • Diameter: 34mm
  • Edge Lettering: “E PLURIBUS UNUM”
  • Reverse: Taller, narrower lettering than standard

Recent Auction: Stack’s Bowers 2022 – $8,968,870


Market Insights & Discovery Potential

Where These Might Surface:

  • European bank vaults (where U.S. gold was sent pre-1914)
  • Old family collections (especially from California Gold Rush descendants)
  • Museum inventories (misattributed coins occasionally discovered)

If You Encounter Potential Rarities:

  1. Document Everything: Take high-resolution photos before moving the coin
  2. Secure Storage: Use a bank vault until authenticated
  3. Contact: Professional numismatists at PCGS or NGC

Want to explore more gold coin rarities? Visit U.S. Gold Coin Encyclopedia

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *