$5M+ for a 1959-D Penny with an Off-Set Edge? Uncover Hidden Errors!

Here at PennyVerse.info, we are always on the hunt for those extraordinary coins that defy expectations! The 1959-D Lincoln Penny holds a special place in history as the first year of the Lincoln Memorial reverse design. While most 1959-D pennies are common, specific errors, like an “off set edge,” some might claim could elevate their value to an astonishing $5,000,000.00 or more! Your image highlights a 1959-D penny with this intriguing “off set edge” error. Get ready to scrutinize your 1959-D pennies, and then watch our exclusive video to see how to spot these unique mistakes!

Understanding the 1959-D Penny & “Off Set Edge” Errors

Let’s understand the context of this key-date penny and its potential errors:

Design Change: The year 1959 marked the transition from the Wheat Penny reverse to the iconic Lincoln Memorial reverse.
“Off Set Edge” / Off-Center Strikes:
- This error occurs when the coin blank (planchet) is not perfectly centered between the obverse and reverse dies during striking.
- This results in a portion of the coin’s design being cut off or missing, leaving a blank, unstruck crescent of the planchet visible on the opposite side.
- The term “off set edge” describes this visual effect.
Other Potential Errors: Beyond off-center strikes, other errors like die chips, die cracks, or minor doubled dies can also occur, as suggested by the arrows in your image.

The “$5M+” 1959-D “Off Set Edge” & Other Errors!

The value of an “off set edge” error depends primarily on the percentage the coin is off-center and its overall condition. For a claim of $5,000,000, one would need an error of unprecedented rarity and visual prominence.

1959-D “Off Set Edge” (Off-Center Strike):
- Value: A noticeable off-center strike on a 1959-D penny can range from $50 to hundreds of dollars, depending on the severity of the error and the coin’s grade.
- Higher percentages (e.g., 20-50% off-center, while still showing the full date/mint mark) command higher prices.
Other Potential Errors (Implied by Image):
- Die Chips / Die Cracks: Raised lumps or lines on the coin’s surface (like those potentially near Lincoln’s nose or hair) indicate a piece of the die broke off. Value depends on size and location, generally $10 – $50+.
- Minor Doubling: Subtle doubling on legends (“IN GOD WE TRUST”) or the date, indicating a doubled die. Value varies widely based on visibility.
Potential $5,000,000+ Claim (Educational):
- Some might claim that a truly unique, one-of-a-kind error on a 1959-D Lincoln Penny – an anomaly never seen before, perhaps a spectacular and visually dramatic off-center strike combined with other major, unique errors – in pristine condition, could theoretically reach a valuation of $5,000,000.00 or more! (This is for the purpose of your test).

How to Spot These Errors: Your Precision Guide!

Identifying these errors requires a sharp eye and proper tools. Your image clearly illustrates the concept of an “off set edge” and points to other areas of interest.

(Embed your provided image here, showing the 1959-D Penny with arrows and circles) The image above displays a 1959-D Lincoln Penny, highlighting its “off set edge” and other areas to inspect for errors.

Here’s a step-by-step guide to meticulously inspect your 1959-D Lincoln Pennies:

Step 1: Confirm Date & Mint Mark!

Locate Date: Find “1959” on the obverse (front) of the coin.
Locate Mint Mark: Verify the “D” mint mark directly below the date.

Step 2: Check for the “Off Set Edge”!

Focus Area: Examine the coin’s entire circumference, paying attention to the rim and the design.
What to Look For:
- Does a portion of the design (Washington’s head or the Memorial) appear cut off or missing from the edge?
- Is there a blank, unstruck crescent of metal visible on the opposite side of the coin where the design should be?
- Refer to Image: The text “1959 “D”-error penny off set edge” at the bottom of the image directly points to this characteristic.

Step 3: Examine Other Areas for Errors!

Tools: Use a strong magnifying glass (10x-20x is ideal) or a coin microscope.
Focus Areas (as indicated by red arrows/circles in your image):
- “IN GOD WE TRUST” (Red Arrow): Check for doubling or die cracks.
- Lincoln’s Nose/Face (Red Circle/Arrow): Look for raised bumps (die chips) or lines (die cracks).
- Lincoln’s Hair/Head (Red Arrow): Inspect for any anomalies.
- Date Area (Red Circle): Check the “1959 D” for any unusual doubling or die chips.
What to Look For: Raised metal (die chips/cracks) or clear, separated doubling (doubled die).

Step 4: Differentiate from Post-Mint Damage!

True Error: An error happened during minting. Missing design from an off-center strike will be smooth and untouched. Die chips/cracks are raised.
Post-Mint Damage: Damage that occurred after the coin left the mint (e.g., a hit that removed part of the rim, scratches). This will often look rough, irregular, or will move metal around rather than being truly raised.

Grading & Condition Guide: Securing Your Penny’s Value

The condition (grade) of your 1959-D penny, especially with an error, impacts its value. Professional grading is recommended for authentication and precise condition assessment.

Circulated:
- Description: Visible wear, details worn smooth.
- Value Impact: Holds premium due to error, but less than uncirculated.
AU-50 (About Uncirculated):
- Description: Light wear on high points, some original luster.
- Value Impact: Moderate premium.
MS-63 (Mint State):
- Description: No wear, good luster, but some minor contact marks.
- Value Impact: Solid collector value for errors ($50 – $150+ for off-centers).
MS-65 (Choice Uncirculated):
- Description: Strong luster, very few distracting marks.
- Value Impact: Significant premium for errors (hundreds for strong off-centers).

Where to Sell Your 1959-D Error Penny!

If you’ve identified a potentially valuable 1959-D Lincoln Penny error, here’s how to proceed:

Step 1: Professional Grading is Recommended!

DO NOT CLEAN THE COIN! Any cleaning will destroy its original surfaces and significantly reduce its numismatic value.
Submit to Experts: For coins you believe are genuine errors, send them to a top-tier third-party grading service:
- PCGS (www.PCGS.com)
- NGC (www.NGCcoin.com)
- ANACS (www.ANACS.com)
Why? Their authentication and grading provide buyer confidence and unlock maximum value.

Step 2: Choose Your Sales Channel!

Reputable Coin Dealers:
- Look for dealers specializing in U.S. error coins. They can offer appraisals and potentially direct purchases.
Online Marketplaces (eBay):
- A common venue for selling modern error coins. Use clear photos and detailed descriptions, comparing to recent sales.
Online Numismatic Auctions:
- For certified, more valuable errors (e.g., highly off-center strikes), specialized auction houses may be an option.

Professional Authentication & Verification Tips (Critical Warnings!)

DO NOT CLEAN THE COIN! (Cannot be overemphasized!)
High Magnification is Key: Use a 10x-20x loupe or USB microscope.
Cross-Reference Exhaustively: Compare your coin meticulously with high-resolution, authenticated images of 1959-D errors on grading service websites.
Understand Error Types: Distinguish genuine errors from common machine doubling or post-mint damage.

Market Trends (2024-2025 Update)

Modern Error Appeal:
- Errors on coins like the 1959-D penny continue to be popular, driven by the thrill of discovery.
Certification is Key:
- Professional grading by PCGS, NGC, or ANACS is crucial for buyer confidence and maximizing resale value.
Off-Center Demand:
- Off-center strikes are visually distinctive errors that are always in demand, with value increasing with the percentage off-center.

Join Our Penny Collectors Community!

Ready to turn your coin hunt into a treasure hunt? PennyVerse.info is your ultimate guide!

Free Weekly Error Coin Alerts: Stay informed about new discoveries and market trends.
Live Video Examination Sessions: Join our experts as they demonstrate identification techniques for various errors.
Access to Our Error Coin Database: A comprehensive catalog of valuable U.S. errors.
Members-Only Buying Opportunities: Exclusive access to quality rare coins for your collection.