These four U.S. coins have shocked the market with prices ranging from $192,000 to over $12 million! 
Let’s explore why these pieces are so valuable and whether you should hold or sell if one ever lands in your collection.
1. 1943 Bronze Lincoln Cent — The $1.7 Million Accident
Record Sale: $1.7 Million (2010)
One of the most famous mint errors in history!
Why It’s Worth Millions
Accidentally struck in 95% copper during WWII
Only 10–15 real specimens known
A legendary, high-demand error coin
Hold or Sell?
Hold long-term — values climb 8–10% yearly
Sell only if you urgently need cash — population is tiny and demand is huge
2. 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar — The First U.S. Dollar Ever 
Record Sale: $12 Million (Finest Known)
The holy grail of early American coinage
Why It’s So Valuable
First silver dollar issued by the United States
Only 140–150 survivors
Massive historical significance
Hold or Sell?
- Hold — this is a long-term blue-chip collectible
- Sell only if you receive $500,000+ for mid-grade examples
3. 1913 Liberty Nickel — The 5-Piece Mystery Coin
Record Sale: $4.5 Million (2018)
A coin surrounded by mystery and controversy
Why It’s Legendary
Only 5 genuine coins in existence
Struck illegally after the design was retired
Museum-level rarity and prestige
Hold or Sell?
- Hold forever — values rarely drop
- MUST be certified (PCGS/NGC) before any sale!
4. 2000-P Sacagawea Mule Dollar — The $192,000 Mistake Coin
Record Sale: $192,000
A modern error worth more than many gold coins!
Why It’s Valuable
Washington quarter obverse + Sacagawea dollar reverse
Only 3 confirmed
Rarest modern U.S. Mint error
Hold or Sell?
- Sell now — modern error prices may be peaking
- Keep only if graded MS67+
2025 Coin Market – What to Hold & What to Sell
Best to HOLD (Long-Term Growth)
Pre-1900 rarities
Coins with fewer than 25 known
High-grade registry coins (MS/PR70)
Best to SELL (2025 Trends)
Uncertified or raw coins
Modern error coins
Duplicates in your collection
Need an Expert Opinion? Get a Free Appraisal
Email: consult@pennyverse.info
Subject: “HOLD OR SELL”
Include:
Clear front/back photos
Certification details (PCGS, NGC, ANACS)
Your collecting or investment goals
