American singer and actress Rachel Zegler fled the musical she was headlining mid-show at London’s Palladium—and if the five-minute standing ovation is anything to go by, her replacement, Bella Brown, was more than up to the task.
Brown, an understudy of Zegler, later took to her Instagram account to revel in her success after her performance.
“What a lucky audience getting to see both myself and MY ANGEL REG ZEG!!” she wrote.
Brown pulled off the ode Don’t Cry for Me Argentina to perfection
Image credits: rachelzegler
During a short hold after the first act on Thursday, June 24, the audience witnessed an announcement that Zeglar had taken ill and that Brown would be filling her shoes.
The second act comprised a reenactment of “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina,” composed by Lloyd Webber and written by Tim Rice.
Had Zegler been present to perform the ode, she would have played the role of Eva, standing on a balcony at the Argentinian Presidential Palace, singing to her supporters.
Image credits: Justin E Palmer/Getty
As Lloyd cast her, she would have stood on an outside veranda of the Palladium while being projected to the audience inside.
Brown was lauded by Broadway Works Instagram for her performance
According to People present for the show, Brown pulled the act off perfectly.
Image credits: Ming Yeung/Getty
“Her performance as Eva throughout the rest of the show carried over the electricity, intensity and vulnerability Zegler had established in Act 1,” the outlet wrote.
And as testimony to her performance, the crowd was so impressed that they applauded her for five minutes at the end of the scene, during which she bowed ten times.
Broadway Works on Instagram serenaded Brown, writing: “Huge shoutout Bella Brown (@bellaelupiabrown) who began tonight’s performance of Evita in the West End in her normal track, The Mistress, but switched to the leading role of EVA PERÓN for Act 2!”
Image credits: bellaelupiabrown
“This is absolutely insane, especially considering she’s only done the role once. What a lucky audience!”
Brown would weigh in, too, writing: “What a lucky audience getting to see both myself and MY ANGEL REG ZEG!!”
Zeglar did not allow another such performance and returned for her role the next day
It appears that Zeglar’s mystery ailment wore off quickly. As promised on her Instagram Stories, she was back on stage for the next day’s installment.
She already noted how important the role was to her in a wordy caption alongside a photo of herself in character at the show’s opening.
“I never thought I would get to live my dream this way,” she wrote. Claiming that she was “surrounded by the most amazing people.”
“I feel so held.”
The public has started comparing Zegler with Brown
Image credits: rachelzegler
Fans weighed in with one commenting: “Would love to see Bella in this role. She’s incredible. Bet the crowd outside got a shock if they knew Rachel started then Bella appears after the interval.”
“She was a legend tonight – and her chemistry with the whole cast – was fabulous and the applause went on for SO long – a magic night to remember,” echoed another.
While the outpouring of praise for Brown and understudies in general appears endless with comments like “Shout out to understudies! That’s got to be stressful!” bearing the general sentiment, some netizens saw fit to make a comparison.
One netizen took issue with Zeglar and wrote: “I hope understudy takes over the part.”
“Once again someone with real talent got to shine. The girl can’t act or sing but ya keep forcing her onto us. Meanwhile ya skipping over REAL talented singers and actors!!” lamented another.
It is not the American actress’s first rodeo
Image credits: rachelzegler
Rachel Zegler is best known for her role in the 2021 Steven Spielberg screen adaptation of West Side Story. In it, she played Maria and won a Golden Globe Award for her theatrics.
Predating this accolade, she played Juliet in director Sam Gold’s contemporalisation of Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, which began in September 2024.
